Growing up well: The role of schools in young people's transition to adulthood

1. Growing up well: What difference can schools make in young peoples transition to adulthood? Sinan Gemici AVETRA OctoberVET 2013 Ballarat

2. Overview

3. Data L ongitudinal S urveys of A ustralian Y outh

4. What is LSAY? Track a nationally representative sample of young Australians as they move from school into post-school destinations Starts at age 15 and covers a 10-year period Collects information about education and training, work, and social development Purpose: To develop an evidence-base on factors that facilitate a successful transition into adulthood

5. Structure of LSAY

6. Want to find out more? www.lsay.edu.au

8. What we know already Policy focus on schools both nationally and internationally 1 School characteristics have been found to influence test scores and year 12 completion 2 1 Gonski et al. 2011; OECD 2010 2 Curtis & McMillan 2008; NOUS Group et al. 2011

9. What we want to know Policy question: Are there school characteristics that policy can influence to improve students transition to higher education? Which school characteristics have a positive impact on: Australian Tertiary Admission Rank (ATAR) scores the probability of university enrolment by age 19

10. Student characteristics Socio-demographic measures Gender, Indigenous Status, Australian born, English spoken at home, SES Academic Performance Combination of mathematics, reading and science scores in PISA Aspirations and Perceptions Year 12 completion plans, tertiary education aspirations, perceptions of school

11. School Demographics Sector Location Size SES Academic achievement Gender mix LBOTE Resources & Capacity Class size Student- teacher ratio Degree of teacher shortage Proportion of certified teachers Proportion of highly qualified teachers Primary resource base Quality of educational materials Academic Orientation Academic pressure from parents Student selection criteria Use of streaming Exposure to work School Autonomy Responsibility for resources Responsibility for the curriculum Influence of business on the curriculum Providing for Student Needs Level of extracurricula r activities Teacher vs. counsellor- based career advice Perceptions of the school experience Competition Competing for students with other schools in the area School characteristics

12. How much do schools matter? ATAR scores Uni Enrolment (accounting for ATAR scores)

13. School Demographics Sector Location Size SES Academic achievement Gender mix LBOTE Resources & Capacity Class size Student- teacher ratio Degree of teacher shortage Proportion of certified teachers Proportion of highly qualified teachers Primary resource base Quality of educational materials Academic Orientation Academic pressure from parents Student selection criteria Use of streaming Exposure to work School Autonomy Responsibility for resources Responsibility for the curriculum Influence of business on the curriculum Providing for Student Needs Level of extracurricula r activities Teacher vs. counsellor- based career advice Perceptions of the school experience Competition Competing for students with other schools in the area Which school characteristics matter for ATAR?

14. Which school characteristics matter most for ATAR?

15. Differences by school sector for ATAR

16. Summary of most important school characteristics School Characteristics ATAR scores Non-government Single-sex Moderate exposure to the world of work Strong parental pressure on schools Larger school size School Characteristics University Enrolment (accounting for ATAR scores) Higher proportion of LBOTE students Non-government Higher SES of student body

17. What we learn from this research School attributes do matter Further research needed to untangle aspects of differentiation (effects of competition, gender separation, streaming) Role of Government schools Non-selective government schools have limited control over some important factors Role of school-level SES deserves attention Impact on higher education equity targets ( 20 per cent of higher education enrolments at the undergraduate level to be from people of a low SES background by 2020) Lets not forget: Successful lives are about more than just ATAR and uni Role of VET in Schools/tertiary VET pathways

19. What we know already Policy focus on low-SES youth (COAG targets) Underprivileged students have lower rates of Year 12 completion and university uptake 1 The quality and socioeconomic profile of a school matters with respect to academic outcomes 2 1 Steering Committee for the Review of Government Service Provision 2011 2 Gonski et al. 2011; OECD 2010; Perry & McConney 2010; Watson & Ryan 2010

20. What we want to know Policy question: Can we improve outcomes by sending low-SES kids to better schools? Do low-SES students benefit from attending high-quality academic schools with respect to Year 12 completion? If so, do they benefit to a greater or lesser extent than their more advantaged peers? What role does individual academic performance play?

21. What is our measure of high academic quality? Top quartile of schools with the highest combined ATAR scores and university enrolment probabilities from the previous paper

22. Results

23. What we learn from this research Academic school quality matters much more for the most vulnerable students: those with poor academic performance and a low-SES background Coming from an advantaged background can insulate students from early school leaving, even in the lowest- quality schools High individual academic performance can offset the negative effects of being low-SES and attending low- quality schools