Diagram .


31 views
Uploaded on:
Category: Business / Finance
Description
Contextual analyses
Transcripts
Slide 1

Layout Case Studies & Testimonials Case examines as proof The misleading impact The clarity issue Correlation & Causation Third factor issue Directionality Selection predisposition

Slide 2

Case thinks about & tributes Case contemplates top to bottom investigations of specific people can\'t be utilized to set up causal relations Testimonials constructive surveys of a man or item

Slide 3

Case ponders as confirmation Historically imperative in Psychology Used by Freud Psychophysics Complex framework can turn out badly in complex ways – sufficient depiction may require such protracted perception that contextual investigation is just suitable approach, at any rate at first

Slide 4

Case considers as proof Most helpful in early phases of research in any zone Useful for improvement of speculations & theories Observation may prompt to ID of significant factors that are controlling or affecting conduct - prompting to hypothesis building

Slide 5

Case examines as confirmation Less valuable for testing hypotheses Case contemplates can\'t discount elective theories Testing speculations requires a control – changing conditions under which individuals play out an assignment to check whether variety in execution anticipated by a hypothesis happens That procedure gives you a chance to set one hypothesis against another, and see which (assuming either) wins

Slide 6

Case ponders as proof The basic thought here is that there can contend records of why something happened. Our assignment as researchers is to look at contending accounts and select one.

Slide 7

Case thinks about as proof If we are to mediate between contending hypotheses, we need to place them in risk . Danger implies that we allow all the contending speculations to not be right. On the off chance that one of them is right in that circumstance, yet the others are, then we dismiss those others and receive the one that survived the test. Control in light of hypothetical expectations makes the required circumstance

Slide 8

Case ponders as confirmation We need to separate between option accounts If there isn\'t a control that gives you a chance to mediate between two speculations – that is, whether they don\'t make distinctive forecasts about execution – then you don\'t have two hypotheses, you just have one. Along these lines, at whatever point you genuinely have two hypotheses, you should have the capacity to test them. In any case, not with contextual analyses.

Slide 9

Case thinks about as confirmation The issue with contextual investigations is that they don\'t give you a chance to make the danger circumstance One sensible record of any change in the state of a contextual analysis subject is the misleading impact . A moment issue is that perceptions on the off chance that reviews can be one-sided by the clarity impact .

Slide 10

Placebo Effect Placebo impact: propensity to report that a treatment has helped, paying little heed to whether it has a genuine restorative impact. Control bunch gets a fake treatment Experimental gathering gets the genuine treatment

Slide 11

Placebo Effect If the two gatherings demonstrate a similar measure of change, then the change is because of misleading impact. On the off chance that control gather demonstrates any change, some portion of treatment impact is misleading impact.

Slide 12

Placebo impact This is about the force of conviction: e.g., - doctors say, when another medication is accessible, "Hustle just a bit and utilize it while despite everything it works" Hawthorne Effect – individuals\' execution showed signs of improvement when other individuals were being watched – conceivably in light of the fact that "somebody wants to think about it" Turing Test – a PC program is keen on the off chance that you can\'t advise whether you\'re conversing with human or PC; issue – individuals see meaning

Slide 13

Bower (1996): Placebo impact of Prozac twice as extensive as impact of the medication itself. Greenberg & Fisher The points of confinement of natural medications for mental pain: examinations with psychotherapy & panacea (1989) From fake treatment to panacea: Putting psychiatric medications to the test (1997) Placebo impacts

Slide 14

Benefits of psychoactive medications are to a great extent because of misleading impacts Brown (SciAm 1998): desires have genuine, quantifiable impacts – recommend fake treatments! Misleading impacts

Slide 15

Placebo impacts are across the board, so they are constantly present as an option record of why somebody improved when they got a treatment. You can\'t discount misleading impacts in the event that reviews. Individuals who got the advantage of misleading impacts may offer tributes, not realizing that it wasn\'t their treatment that had the effect. Misleading impacts conclusions

Slide 16

The Vividness Issue Retrieval from memory is affected by distinctiveness . E.g.: which is more secure, go via auto or go via plane? Factually, go via plane is much more secure, yet many individuals think it is more hazardous. Why? One record: reports of plane accidents are distinctive, so effectively recovered from memory – ease inclinations gauge of whether flying is protected.

Slide 17

The Vividness Issue Stanovich: <680 auto, truck, & bike mischance passings/wk in the U.S. Be that as it may, (Stanovich says) individuals don\'t call for activity since they don\'t perceive the issue Lots of reports of maybe a couple passings aren\'t as striking as one report of a plane crash with many passings

Slide 18

Criticism: For the situation of plane versus auto travel, Stanovich doesn\'t realize that the activity security issue is not perceived – that is quite recently his feeling. He just realizes that individuals don\'t react as significantly to movement passings as they would to comparative quantities of plane crash passings But there\'s a contrast between not calling for examinations and not reacting …

Slide 19

Criticism Gerald Wilde, Queen\'s University – homeostatic hypothesis of hazard: individuals set an adequate hazard rate for exercises like driving If driving conditions change so as to move drivers far from their favored rate, they alter their conduct to move back to that rate.

Slide 20

Criticism e.g., better brakes? Drive quicker. speed constrain decreased? Give careful consideration individuals are delicate to driving dangers – their conduct varies in ways that are touchy to dangers however they may not know about that variety in their conduct or have the capacity to explain those dangers as insights.

Slide 21

Criticism Perhaps teachers (counting Stanovich) over-esteem the capacity to eloquent information and underestimate the capacity to regulate conduct without such learning.

Slide 22

In the new (8 th ) version of his book, Stanovich has added a capability to his remarks about clarity, recognizing that he utilizes clear cases himself. He now says that he utilizes striking cases to make his focuses huge, yet he additionally gives references to logical proof to those focuses. The last constitute "evidence" of those focuses. The Vividness Issue

Slide 23

Stanovich says that he utilizes striking cases simply because they are important – so in his psyche, probably, the peruser will be convinced by the refered to logical reviews, not the distinctive illustrations But rather will this be the situation? Will his qualification amongst "outline" and "evidence" be as critical to perusers as it is to him? The Vividness Issue

Slide 24

The Vividness Issue Let\'s recognize the thoughts included: 1. Do striking illustrations demonstrate claims? 2. Are conventional individuals unsophisticated customers of proof? 3. Does striking quality assume any valuable part in our reasoning?

Slide 25

1. Do clear cases demonstrate claims? No. As a specialized point, Stanovich is very ideal on this score.

Slide 26

2. Are common individuals unsophisticated buyers of proof? No. As Wilde\'s homeostatic hypothesis of hazard, and the proof he reports, propose, conventional individuals react judiciously to changes in conditions, however they will be unable to verbalize those progressions or the reason for their reactions. The "knowledge of group"

Slide 27

3. Does striking quality assume any helpful part in our reasoning? Our loving for striking illustrations – which Stanovich himself exploits – mirrors an essential truth about human perception: Individual cases help people to grasp occasions or thoughts that are generally past comprehension. As Stalin stated, "1 passing is a catastrophe. 1 million passings is a measurement."

Slide 28

3. Does clarity assume any helpful part in our reasoning? As Stalin stated, "1 demise is a catastrophe. 1 million passings is a measurement." To show this point, how about we use for instance the Holocaust…

Slide 29

The Holocaust 6 million Jews, and numerous other individuals (Gypsies, gays) were killed in Germany and German-possessed domains amid World War II. A horrendous thing – yet how shocking? We don\'t have any measuring scale that gives us a chance to answer that question. Does it find out around one casualty?

Slide 30

Ir è ne N é mirovsky Russian-conceived Jewish essayist Moved to France as a kid, in 1919, after Russian Revolution Published first novel in 1929; celebrated as a splendid writer She was rejected French citizenship in 1938. Left Paris after German control of France in 1940, went to live in a country town with spouse & 2 little girls Continued written work

Slide 31

Paper was rare, so she wrote in modest letters, with an amplifying glass Wrote a novel about the German control of France Arrested by French police in July 1942 before her two youthful girls. Told the girls she was leaving on a trek Ir è ne N é mirovsky

Slide 32

Died of typhus in a German inhumane imprisonment one month later Husband captured, kicked the bucket in Auschwitz gas chamber in November 1942 Daughters monitored by Catholic nuns & ministers through the war, and accommodated by Ir è ne\'s distributer & a companion amid and after the war Ir è ne N é mirovsky

Slide 33

Daughters survived the war, kept a bag containing their moms\' last compositions. after 30 years, girl Dianne put in 20 years translating Ir è ne\'s novel Suite Francaise , working with an amplifying glass. Book was distributed in France in 2004, and a

Recommended
View more...