Future Water Availability in the West: Will there be sufficient .


44 views
Uploaded on:
Description
We are right now in the grasp of a staggering dry spell in a great part of the West
Transcripts
Slide 1

Future Water Availability in the West: Will there be sufficient? Michael Dettinger, USGS, Scripps Institution of Oceanography, La Jolla, CA with commitments from Julio Betancourt, Dan Cayan, & others

Slide 2

OUTLINE Natural varieties of water accessibility Projected nursery impacts on water accessibility Uncertainties & techniques

Slide 3

Drought Index, April 2003 We are presently in the grasp of a staggering dry season in a great part of the West…

Slide 4

But, such dry seasons are simply some portion of the actually repeating scope of occasions in the West... Wet mid 14 th Century NM Spanish Colonization & Encomienda Post-1976 Step change Colo. Waterway overallocation Casas Grandes/Hohokam fall 1899-1904 Drought Great Drought Late 16 th Cent. Megadrought 50\'s Drought Pueblo Revolt politeness of Julio Betancourt, USGS, Tucson

Slide 5

Medieval megadroughts Precipitation reproductions Red : Great Basin PC precipitation remaking Blue : Methusela Walk bristlecone kindness, Malcolm Hughes … and dry spells in the West are not really restricted to the sort that we have known and suited amid the previous 100 years or somewhere in the vicinity. Scott Stine\'s Mono Lake treestumps Mega-dry spells have diminished spillover from the eastern Sierra Nevada for around 100 years each, in any event twice in the previous 1000 years… with maintained streamflow decreases of - 30%!

Slide 6

Temperature recreations from upper treeline: bristlecone pine San Francisco Peaks, AZ Precipitation reproductions from lower treeline: Douglas fir, ponderosa, pinyon pine Consistently hotter; perseveringly drier, then wetter than the past 1400 years! Notwithstanding highlighting the incidental megadrought in the West, such reviews demonstrate the profoundly abnormal character of the twentieth Century, … from Matt Salzer, in press

Slide 7

… and, e.g., the twentieth Century yielded less than-"ordinary" sharp (profound, brief) dry seasons in California. visit Numbers of Short sharp dry seasons Sequoia recreations uncommon cordiality, Malcolm Hughes - > Can the water frameworks of the late twentieth Century suit a less kindhearted atmosphere? (Either with OR without a dangerous atmospheric devation… )

Slide 8

Historical soon, a worldwide temperature alteration patterns are probably going to be superimposed upon these "ordinary" atmosphere varieties that our foundations & organizations suit... … because of increasing speeds of the nursery impact that started 30+ years back!

Slide 9

Under this (confined) compelling, atmosphere models yield a moderately contract scope of warming situations for the West. Yearly TEMPERATURE OVER CENTRAL ROCKIES

Slide 10

No more cooler than "typical" years after around 2025! Indeed, even in the coolest of these models, temperatures start ascending in the 1970s, and unequivocal change may be normal by the 2020s. from ACPI Parallel-Climate demonstrate reenactments,

Slide 11

With just this warming ( i.e. no precipitation changes included, yet ) would come less snowfall, more precipitation, & prior snowmelt… Dettinger et al., in press

Slide 12

So that by the center of the 21st Century, even in the coolest of the models, significant decreases in snowpacks of the Sierra and Rockies are anticipated ... Knowles & Cayan, GRL, 2002

Slide 13

All this outcomes in prior overflow . Merced River above Yosemite Valley Dettinger et al., in press

Slide 14

Projected streamflow timings, 2080-99 versus 1951-80 … all through the West. Stewart et al., in press … and we as of now watch 30+ years of such patterns in streamflow records everywhere throughout the West. Dettinger and Cayan, 1995;Cayan et al., 2001

Slide 15

With this spillover leaving the watersheds prior, summer conditions will be substantially drier and summer streamflow will decrease. NOTE: Unless summer precipitation increments especially, the late spring stream decrease is NOT brought on by expanded dissipation. Dettinger et al., in press

Slide 16

In numerous settings, this change in streamflow timing will mean less overflow caught in Sierran and Rockies stores , … TOTAL RIVER DISCHARGE, APRIL-JULY from ACPI Parallel-Climate show recreations, Dettinger et al, in press

Slide 17

… in light of the fact that the change would likewise involve more serious winter surges . Dettinger et al., in press; http://www.cgd.ucar.edu/cas/ACACIA/workshops/precip/dettinger.pdf

Slide 18

The store supervisor\'s dilemma: Save the water for warm-season employments? Or, on the other hand keep up heaps of exhaust surge control space behind the dams?

Slide 19

20% more spills half more deficiencies Notably, even the little recorded planning shifts on the upper Merced would yield more overflows & more shortfalls ( in a fanciful supply under straightforward FIXED principles ). All in all, how well will such anticipated movements (inside the year) of the accessibility & dangers of supply be taken care of by ebb and flow water frameworks?

Slide 20

wetter drier Under a similar nursery constraining, atmosphere models give less accord in regards to precipitation in the West. Yearly PRECIPITATION OVER CENTRAL ROCKIES

Slide 21

wetter drier Will the West be wetter or drier? We don\'t have the foggiest idea. Some more established models (*) yielded wetter; more current ones by and large are yielding little changes. * ANNUAL PRECIPITATION OVER CENTRAL ROCKIES * … and, in the board, Marty Hoerling may talk about a situation under which we would see significant Western dry-ness.

Slide 22

Overall precipitation From whatever is left of the ppt occasions Precipitation sum, implies moved From the biggest 5% of ppt occasions 1900 1990 2080 But even in the models that venture little change in normal precipitation, extraordinary precipitation occasions increment notably. Anticipated TRENDS IN PRECIPITATION BETWEEN 30N-60N That is, all the pattern is in the enormous tempests! from ACPI Parallel-Climate show recreations,

Slide 23

Merced With enough extra precipitation ( about 2x in this illustration ), the winter snowpack & spring snowmelt seasons can survive a direct warming (+3.5ºC), … Changes in month to month mean streamflow by 2090s Changes in month to month mean snowpack by 2090s Wilby & Dettinger , 2000

Slide 24

… yet with substantially bigger winter surges ! (10x today, for this situation) Wilby & Dettinger, 2000 - > Can we make every one of the tradeoffs important to suit even a wetter (hotter) atmosphere?

Slide 25

How certain would we say we are of such projections? Truly unverifiable, all in all, since… Climate models are not by any stretch of the imagination free "examples" without bounds,… Some AGCM ancestries altered from Edwards, 2000

Slide 26

… outflows situations may not be as exact as the determinations now utilized infer, … Historical IPCC 2001 territory Castles & Henderson updates?

Slide 27

Clouds & science Biogeochemical inputs … and current atmosphere models do exclude all the critical normal procedures and human effects that will be grinding away. For instance… Deforestation & arrive changes Asian Brown Cloud & other unaccounted-for radiative forcings Abrupt changes & shocks

Slide 28

Thus… Large instabilities exist in environmental change projections (and also in the "normal" future) of water supply, yet … The potential for effects on water accessibility are sufficiently expansive to … * Suggest that environmental change postures dangers that merit tending to even at this point.

Slide 29

Metropolitan Water District\'s reaction to dubious future requests may give an educational simple… Large instabilities (+ or - half) exist popular projections by 2050, so MWD… Develops particular techniques to cover widely appealing projection throughout the following 50 yrs. - > If request development is slower than anticipated, buildout can be changed in accordance with take longer than 50 yrs. - > If request is speedier, buildout can be finished sooner and extra arranges will be created again before 50 yrs.

Slide 30

So, will there be sufficient water? Enough-to-get-through another-twentieth Century won\'t be sufficient for the 21st Century. In any case, as opposed to simply getting more supplies, environmental change instabilities imply that Flexibility/vigor should be center until further notice. Uplifting news: Water chiefs in numerous settings are now reexamining plans & operations to suit: changing conditions on the Colorado jeopardized fisheries and environments quick moving toward points of confinement of supply (versus request). We have to give the apparatuses to incorporate atmosphere versatility in the present updates.

Recommended
View more...