Ramifications of Ethnic Diversity: Nnadozie-Chapter 8 .


47 views
Uploaded on:
Category: Sales / Marketing
Description
Rundown Outline-Chap.8. 1.Introduction 2. Ethnicity
Transcripts
Slide 1

Ramifications of Ethnic Diversity: Nnadozie-Chapter 8 How does ethnic differences Affect the Economies of Africa?

Slide 2

Summary Outline-Chap.8 1.Introduction 2. Ethnicity & Economic Growth: information holes? 3. Ethnic Diversity & Politics… A. Ethnic Diversity in Democracies B. Ethnicity in Dictatorships C. Some Testable Hypothesis D. Exact discoveries

Slide 3

Summary Outline-chap. 8 cont. 4. Under What conditions does Ethnic Diversity Cause Civil clash and War ? A. Financing of Rebellion B. Exact Evidence 5. Arrangement Implications 6. Synopsis

Slide 4

Introduction ( in light of article by Paul Collier in Nnadozie book ) Ethnic clashes have progressively turned out to be real worries far and wide… Africa\'s destitution might be to some degree because of its ethnic differences?? (Easterly and Levine) Ethnic differing qualities makes collaboration troublesome. Decision : With couple of particular exemptions, ethnic differing qualities neither increments common war nor decreases financial development in vote based systems . Dictator run is exemption

Slide 5

2. What doe we think about Ethnicity and monetary execution Knowledge holes Ethnicity is a social wonder It is characteristic.. Ethnicity (like religion) as a political wonder is more liquid and can be conceivably dangerous. Case, Islamic Fundamentalism is a politicized creating genuine clashes in Muslim and different Societies. However, family relationship in conventional social orders can be and proficient reason for aggregate activity (Posner). Why? Family gatherings are productive reactions to the data and contract requirement issues display in present day showcase economies, however ailing in customary/African economies.

Slide 6

2. What doe we think about Ethnicity and monetary execution?- Knowledge crevices Given that ethnicity can be a reason for social and political character, what are the outcomes? Ethnic differences or separation can be measured by the record of ethno-semantic fractionalization (ELF). This record ranges from 0 (homogenous) to 1 (greatest separation). Watched reaches are from 0 to 0.93

Slide 7

2. What doe we think about Ethnicity and monetary execution?- Knowledge holes Ethnic assorted qualities can be sorted as: 1. Ethnic predominance ,- illustration Malaysia, South Africa, Canada, and so on 2. Ethnic discontinuity makes insubordination more troublesome. One basis for disobedience is in Africa is monetary . The differential capacity of revolt associations to raise back, relies on upon the open doors for predation of essential normal assets, product fares and commitment of diaspora groups. Exampl e-Liberia under Charles Taylor utilized precious stones to fund insubordination.

Slide 8

2. What doe we think about Ethnicity and financial execution? Cont. Investigate indicates ethnic predominance pairs the danger of common war, fracture may lessen hazard, particularly under autocracies. Ethnic Fragmentation makes defiance troublesome due to absence of union to frame outfitted gatherings.

Slide 9

3.Does Ethnic Diversity Lead to Dysfunctional Politics? The contention that ethnic differing social orders require a solid pioneer to maintain a strategic distance from struggle is a most loved contentions for Dictators. Nigeria Military tyrants utilized this a reason to hang on power or decline to yield regular citizen fair administer for a considerable length of time. Each time the Military assumed control in Nigeria, it utilized ethnic resistance as a reason to come to control.

Slide 10

3.The Effect of Ethnic Diversity A. The Case of Ethnic Diversity in Democracies if there should be an occurrence of ethnic predominance, difference and imbalance would be critical. For instance, In South Africa where blacks holds 65% of the vote (after 1994-downfall of politically-sanctioned racial segregation), and whites and Asians have higher wages, ethnic legislative issues conveys arrangements that augments the prosperity of the 33 rd percentile rather than 50th percentile with ethnic free governmental issues.

Slide 11

3. The Effect of Ethnicity in Democracies Ethnic strength presents tough power on a triumphant coalitions which then has a motivating force to give up development for redistribution. Constrained ethnic discontinuity may encourage helpful results that keeps away from or decreases the expenses of temperamental least winning coalitions. The more noteworthy the degree of discontinuity, the more troublesome it is to achieve a helpful arrangement.

Slide 12

3. The Effect of Ethnicity in Democracies What happens when ethnicity is smothered ? In 1960s Uganda and Nigerian Political gatherings were ethnic based. After a time of tyranny, popular government was built up with established changes to smother old gatherings. In Uganda lawmakers can just crusade as people there are no political gatherings, in view of the dread of ethnic or tribal clashes. In Nigeria two new gatherings were forced by withdrawing military administrations with the prerequisite that they be multi-ethnic.

Slide 13

The Effect of Ethnic Diversity Under Dictatorship without balanced governance, principles and constitutions tend abuse common and property rights.. In Ethnically different social orders, tribal loyalties might be valuable in keeping up military union illustration: Saddam Hussein\'s control of the Iraqi Army by means of his Tikriti faction of the Sunni Muslims . In any case, they are not feasible over the long haul. An uncommon altruistic tyrant who prevails with regards to acknowledging picks up from social arranging might be adequately prevalent not to need military support. Ex. Kwan Yew of Singapore .

Slide 14

The Effect of Ethnic Diversity Under Dictatorship The relationship between ethnic attachment and the power base of autocracy has essential ramifications.. The all the more ethnically fractionalized the general public, the smaller the most extreme military bolster base of the autocracy, the more outlandish for resistance. On the normal ruthless autocracy will have a smaller bolster base the all the more ethnically fractionalized the general public.

Slide 15

Ethnic Diversity, Dictatorship and Democracy-Testable speculation The imaginable impacts of ethnic assorted qualities in various political frameworks is given in table 8.1 page 163 of Nnadozie content. Ethnic assorted qualities is anticipated to harm when ethnic predominance and fascism exist together. Past tyranny, ethnic discontinuity does not seem to deliver any more regrettable governmental issues than ethnic homogeneity, and the political framework may work better.

Slide 16

Ethnicity and type of Governance: Empirically Testing the Hypotheses Using information 1960-90, the impact of ethnic differences was tried. A measure of ethnic assorted qualities (ELF) demonstrated ethnic differences connects with a measure of political rights. This connection term is exceedingly huge and expansive. Ethnic differing qualities might not have antagonistic impacts in completely democratized social orders, but rather decreases financial development up to 3% in tyranny.

Slide 17

Empirical Results 1. The impact of Ethnic Diversity : Easterly and Levine speculation that ethnic assorted qualities may prompt to terrible political or strategy choices. In vote based systems ethnic differing qualities does not negatively affect the economy, but rather in fascism ethnicity is probably going to increase savage conduct, and accordingly hurtful on society. Likewise, the speculation that impact of ethnic predominance has negative impact is not bolstered in popular governments. i.e. Ethnic differences does not adversely influence monetary execution in free and equitable social orders. Cases, USA, India, and so forth

Slide 18

Ethnicity and Conflict 4. Are there conditions when Ethnic Diversity Cause Civil War ? A. Financing of Rebellion B. Observational Evidence 5. Approach Implications 6. Outline

Slide 19

4. Does Ethnic Diversity Cause Civil War? Standard contention : Rebels ascend because of some "inspiration" or "inclinations" Alternative theory : How they are orgranized and financed matters.. Ethnicity influences the danger of contention through different ways.

Slide 20

A.The Financing of Rebellion The capacity of dissidents to manage themselves, to some degree, relies on accessibility of money related sources… i.e.There is a fund inspiration in resistance. This source is frequently predation of essential product sends out Diamonds, Gold, Oil, and so forth.. Danger of resistance will builds reliance on essential wares, and declines per capita wage and development..

Slide 21

Financing Rebellion Much of the insubordination as of late is for withdrawal roused by product rents. Illustrations : Civil war in Sierra Leone was over precious stone fields.Conflict in Zaire was over copper and jewels in the southeast of this nation.. Nigeria\'s contention( Biafra war in 1960s) was because of oil revelations in the area. Columbia\'s war was over Cocaine. The severance of Eritrea was roused, to a limited extent, because of control of Red Sea Coast to concentrate lease… ..

Slide 22

Empirical Evidence Collier and Hoeffler tried a factual model to clarify strife for 161 nations over from 1960-99, with 1288 perceptions. 73 of which prompted to common war, characterized as: " where no less than 1000 battle related passings … ". The impact of essential products particularly under fascisms in these contentions and wars is intense …

Slide 23

Empirical Evidence cont. Ethnicity enters the exact financial model three ways : 1. Minority Ethnic strength in dictatorial states expands defiance and common clash altogether. Cases: Rwanda, Iraq, and so forth … 2.Ethnic divided states may not be powerless to insubordination. For instance, Irian Jaya region of Indonesia with essential fares did not posture noteworthy insubordination to Indonesia, because of 450 dialect aggregates in this area.. 3.Ethnicity additionally enters the mode through diasporas living abroad. Case incorporate Irish Americans in IRA, Jewish Americans in Israel, Eritreans-EPLF, Overseas Somali\'s contributed cash to different revolts and War Lords in view of Clan,that prompted to the crumple of the Somale state in 1991.

Slide 24

Policy Implications 1. Ethnically assorted majority rules systems really have less clash than homogenous social orders. Case: An illustration is Somalis in the Horn of A

Recommended
View more...