Supporting Our Capacity to Give Palliative Consideration.

Uploaded on:
Palliative Care. Palliative Care Update 2009. David F. Giansiracusa, MD ... Self consideration empowers doctors (clinicians) to administer to their patients ...
Slide 1

Slide 2

Sustaining Our Ability to Provide Palliative Care Palliative Care Update 2009 David F. Giansiracusa, MD Director, Palliative Care Program Maine Medical Center Portland, Maine

Slide 3

I have no pertinent monetary connections to reveal. David F. Giansiracusa, M.D.

Slide 4

Why talk about empathy exhaustion, burnout, and self-care at a Palliative Care symposium ?

Slide 5

" Physicians (clinicians) working with patients toward the end of life much of the time need to react to overpowering human enduring… .Self consideration is a key part of the helpful command. Self consideration empowers doctors (clinicians) to nurture their patients reasonably with more prominent sympathy, affectability, adequacy, and compassion." "The heart should first pump blood to itself." (Kearney M. JAMA. 2009;301(11):1157)

Slide 6

Lack of self-consideration may have genuine expert & individual outcomes

Slide 7

Objectives Define empathy exhaustion and burnout and their causes and results. Address hazard elements. Perceive burnout and sympathy exhaustion in oneself. Gotten comfortable with what people and associations may do to counteract and lighten burnout and empathy weariness.

Slide 8

Compassion Fatigue Experience of passionate exhaustion because of the torment of another Secondary or vicarious injury Evolves from the relationship of the clinician with the patient in the setting of an irregularity of self-care and care of others (Figley CR. Empathy Fatigue, 1995.)

Slide 9

Symptoms of Compassion Fatigue: Like Those of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder Hyper-excitement : crabbiness, aggravated rest, hyper-carefulness Avoidance: "not having any desire to go there" Re-encountering: meddlesome considerations or dreams, mental or physiological misery of indications of work with biting the dust or enduring (Figley CR. Sympathy Fatigue, 1995)

Slide 10

WHAT CHARACTERIZES BURNOUT? Overpowering enthusiastic and interpersonal employment focuses on that make a lopsidedness of expert requests and rewards Arises from anxieties of the clinician\'s cooperation with the workplace Results in disappointment, weakness, and failure to accomplish work objectives

Slide 11

Manifestations of Burnout Emotional Exhaustion: - Depletion - Irritability/outrage - Depression/blame Depersonalization: - Cynicism - Feelings of hatred - Withdrawal Reduced feeling of individual achievement: - Negative self-idea - Complaining without offering an answer (Maslach, Schaufeli, Leiter, Annual Reviews Psychology 2001)

Slide 12

Distinction Between Burnout and Depression Burnout just includes a man\'s relationship to his or her work Depression universally influences a man\'s life (Maslach C, Jackson SE, Leiter MP. Burnout Inventory Manual. 3 rd ed. Palo Alto, California: Consulting Psychologists Press, 1996)

Slide 13

Exhaustion Experienced, additionally  Prompts activity to separation oneself candidly and intellectually from one\'s work as an approach to adapt

Slide 14

Depersonalization Coping instrument of removing oneself from those one looks after Results in neglecting to value the qualities which make beneficiaries extraordinary and connecting with individuals

Slide 15

Reduced Sense of Personal Accomplishment May create in parallel, instead of successively with weariness and depersonalization Contributor: Lack of pertinent assets as opposed to work over-burden and social clash

Slide 16

The Six Areas of Work Life Workload Control Reward Community Fairness Values (Maslach D, Leiter MP. 1997 The Truth about Burnout. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass)

Slide 17

The "Match/Mismatch" Theoretical Framework of Burnout: Of six areas of occupation: Greater the hole or befuddle, more prominent the probability of burnout Greater the fit, the more noteworthy the probability of engagement with work (Maslach and Leiter. The Truth About Burnout.)

Slide 18

Varying Importance of the Six Components of Work Not clear the amount of a confound people can endure: May rely on upon: - Particular zone - Pattern of different zones For instance, with significant prizes, agreeable working association with partners, feeling that work is refreshing, individuals may endure much more prominent workload (Maslach and Leiter. The Truth About Burnout)

Slide 19

Personal Consequences of Burnout Stress, Anxiety, Anger, Depression Substance mishandle Family interruption Stress-related wellbeing issues (Maslach, Schaufeli, Leiter. Work burnout. Yearly Reviews Psychology . 2001)

Slide 20

Pathologic Associations with Burnout Increased occurrence of cardiovascular illness, Type 2 diabetes, weakened richness, poor self-rating of wellbeing Psychoneuroimmunological components  aggravation In ladies, burnout connected with higher CRP and fibrinogen levels In men, CRP and fibrinogen levels connected with misery (Mayer and Watkins, 1998; Toker el al. 2005)

Slide 21

Self-Care Not So Soft After All Depression in: 12% of male doctors, 18% of female doctors; 15-30% of restorative understudies and occupants After mishaps, suicide is the most widely recognized reason for death among therapeutic understudies Doctors and medical caretakers at higher danger for suicide Doctors 70% higher death rates from self-perpetrated harm (Frank et al. 2000) As numerous as 400 doctors confer suicide every year in the United States. (Alessandra Strada, PhD. AAHPM meeting, 2009)

Slide 22

"Doctors (clinicians) are not simply bearers of information and aptitudes, imperatively vital as those may be, however are themselves the instruments of consideration." __Eric Cassell, The Nature of Suffering and the Goals of Medicine , New York: Oxford, 2004

Slide 23

Job-Related Consequences of Burnout Decreased employment execution (Parker, Kulik, J Behav Med 1995) Reduced responsibility to work (Leiter, Harvie, Frizzell. Soc Sci Med 1998) Low profession fulfillment (Goldberg et al. Acad Emerg Med 1996) (Lemkau, Rafferty, Gordon. Fam Pract Res J 1994)

Slide 24

Clinical Consequences of Burnout-May Lead to Poor Patient Care Prolonged healing center stays Lack of dialog of patients\' and relatives\' inclinations and objectives of consideration Patient and family feeling a feeling of surrender Excessive utilization of innovative intercessions

Slide 26

Who Is At Risk of Burnout? Callings with Intense Involvement with People Physicians (rates going 25% to 60%) (Gunderson. Ann Intern Med 2001) (Ramirez et al. "Burnout and psychiatric confusion among malignancy clinicians" Br J Cancer 1995) Nurses (Kilfedder, Power, Wells. Soc Sci Med 1998) Educators (Chernis. Past Burnout . NY:Routledge, 1995) Clergy (Kirk Byron Jones. Rest in the Storm)

Slide 27

Risk Factors for Burnout Being a more youthful guardians Having obligation regarding wards: kids or guardians Being single Being exceptionally energetic with serious interest in one\'s calling Lacking consciousness of one\'s own physical and enthusiastic needs

Slide 28

Risk Factors for Burnout in Medical Residents Caring for patients with extreme ailment and enduring Having restricted associations with patients and families - time, part on human services group Feeling a need to save, fix-it Facing troublesome correspondence challenges ("get the DNR")

Slide 29

Burnout in Medical Residents 87 (76%) of inward drug inhabitants (115 or 76% reacting to study) met criteria for burnout: - More prone to self-report imperfect patient consideration which was connected with criticism and depersonalization (Shanafelt, Bradley, Wipf, Back. Burnout and self-reported patient consideration in an inner drug residency program. Ann Intern Med 2002;136:358-367)

Slide 30

Residents\' Self-Reports of Providing Suboptimal Care "I released patients to make the administration "reasonable" on the grounds that the group was so occupied." "I didn\'t completely talk about treatment choices or answer a patient\'s inquiries." "I requested restrictions or meds for a disturbed patient without assessing." "I didn\'t play out an analytic test in view of craving to release a patient." (Shanafelt, AIM , 2002)

Slide 31

Self-Reports of Residents Who Experienced Burnout "I gave careful consideration to the social or individual effect of an ailment on a patient." "I had minimal passionate response to the demise of one of my patients." "I felt regretful about how I treated a patient from a philanthropic viewpoint." (Shanafelt. Point , 2002)

Slide 32

Even Experienced Clinicians May Feel: " a feeling of disappointment and dissatisfaction when the patient\'s ailment advances, a feeling of feebleness against disease and its related misfortunes, (unrecognized) sorrow, an apprehension of turning out to be sick oneself, or a yearning to isolate from and stay away from patients to get away from these emotions." (Meier et al. JAMA 2001)

Slide 33

" The most noticeably bad forlornness is to not be OK with one\'s self." __ Mark Twain

Slide 34

Health Care Professionals\' Vulnerability to Burnout Work intimately with patients and families who are strongly enduring, In emergency, and frequently in struggle  The "Helping Rod Effect" Conversations require time, center, and enthusiastic and scholarly vitality (Meier and Beresford, J Pall Med , October 2006)

Slide 35

Clinicians Experience Constant introduction to death Inadequate time with passing on patients Growing workload and expanding passings Inadequate adapting to one\'s own particular passionate reaction to kicking the bucket patients Need to bear on in wake of patient passings Communication challenges with biting the dust patients and relatives Inability to satisfy one�

View more...