Group Visits For Tobacco Cessation Get Paid More to Produce Better Clinical Outcomes This session is supported in part by a grant to the AAFP from the Smoking Cessation Leadership Center
Evidence-based recommendations: • All patients should be asked if they use tobacco and should have their tobacco-use status documented on a regular basis. Evidence has shown that this significantly increases rates of clinician intervention.Strength of evidence: A • Clinic screening systems such as expanding the vital signs to include tobacco-use status, or the use of other reminder systems such as chart stickers or computer prompts are essential for the consistent assessment, documentation, and intervention with tobacco use. Strength of evidence: B Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality Clinical Guidelines and Evidence Reports (AHRQ) http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/bv.fcgi?rid=hstat2.section.7838
Evidence-based recommendations: • All physicians should strongly advise every patient who smokes to quit because evidence shows that physician advice to quit smoking increases abstinence rates.Strength of evidence: A • All clinicians should strongly advise their patients who use tobacco to quit. Although studies have not independently addressed the impact of advice to quit by all types of nonphysician clinicians, it is reasonable to believe that such advice is effective in increasing their patients' long-term quit rates.Strength of evidence: B Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality Clinical Guidelines and Evidence Reports (AHRQ) http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/bv.fcgi?rid=hstat2.section.7838
Question for audience: Do you currently offer group visits? • Yes – for tobacco cessation • Yes – for conditions other than tobacco use • No
Outline • What are group visits? • Why should you offer group visits? • What are the outcomes from using groups visits? • How do you organize and schedule a group visit? • How do you bill & document a group visit? • How do you apply group visit techniques to tobacco cessation?
“Skeptical scrutiny is the means...by which deep insights can be winnowed from deep nonsense.” --Carl Sagan
What kinds of patients benefit most from group visits? • High-risk patients: • Those patients who have an increased risk for both high resource utilization and poor outcomes • Tobacco users are certainly at high risk for both
High-risk groups • Diabetes • Tobacco users • Asthma • Cardiovascular disease (CVD) • Dyslipidemia • Depression • Total joint replacements • Frail elderly • HIV/AIDS
We can afford to focus on high-risk patients • 1 percent of the population accounts for 20 to 30 percent of health care expenses • 5 percent of the population accounts for 50 percent of total expenses • Insurers are starting to fund and encourage group visits, even if they increase physician revenue
Shared medical visits that provide an effective way to manage high-risk cohorts • Maximize educational time by working with 15 to 30 patients at a time • Many patients prefer group visits • Group visits offer a billable service • Any medical provider can offer group visits • Doctors, nurses, PAs, pharmacists, mental therapists, dieticians, etc. A physician and a dietician can even do a visit together • Attendance drops if primary physician is not involved
Group visits can be annual, in a series, or longitudinal • Annual visits share information and reach set targets for the group’s diagnosis (e.g., an osteoporosis visit or a single tobacco cessation group visit) • Series group visits consist of 2 to 3 visits focused on tobacco cessation (e.g., initial and one 2 to 4 weeks later) • Longitudinal group visits can substitute for many individual doctor visits (e.g., type 2 diabetes, but could also be used for patients with tobacco use and other related major health issues)
Difference between a group visit and a class: • Class only provides information to a group • A group medical visit may include both an individual E/M service and group education or individual E/M services observed by the group. • The individual E/M service is a billable service. Group education may be billable. • In a group visit you must spend one-on-one time to clarify the subjective, objective, assessment and plan for the visit.
Models for shared medical appointments During the early 1990s, we had three models: • Diagnosis-specific group visits (Masley) • Pick a diagnosis and invite those patients (e.g., tobacco abuse) • Cooperative clinics (Scott, Internist, Kaiser) • Invite a group with different diagnoses to get their care together (frail elderly) • DIGMAS: Drop-in Group Medical Appointments (Noffsinger, Psychologist, Kaiser & Private) • A system to help with access Now, many models exist
Provider and Behaviorist Models • In the high-risk cohort model, I’ve done visits with myself and a few medical assistants • In the Cooperative Clinic and DIGMA models, you always invite a behaviorist to moderate the group • Residents do well with a behaviorist present • You don’t require a behaviorist; family physicians are great with people
Models for Group Visits • No “right model,” just the one that works for you and your patients • The model you use is based upon • The goals for your patients • Your patients’ diagnoses • Your reimbursement needs • Available office space
The model you choose should: • Improve clinical outcomes • Increase your productivity by about 15 to 25 percent • Improve both patient and provider satisfaction • Lower total health care costs
Succeed in changing lifestyles with group visits • Group visits help many patients succeed in making lifestyle changes, such as in quitting tobacco use • Involve partners & family in changes • Groups visits have been shown to improve dietary intake and activity levels; which help to address weight gain concerns related to tobacco cessation
Why should you offer group visits? Share more information in less time Improve clinical outcomes Improve patient satisfaction for many patients Save money on the cost of providing care Increase productivity Improve provider satisfaction This is a rare Win-Win-Win opportunity
Outcome Data From Group Visit Studies We need more data on Group Visits in particular related to tobacco cessation
“Men occasionally stumble over the truth, but most of them pick themselves up and hurry off as if nothing had happened.” --Winston Churchill
Outcome Data • Data shows group visits improve quality of clinical outcomes, patient satisfaction with care, cost data, & MD productivity • This includes for diabetes, HTN, prenatal visits, asthma, etc. • While group visits have been used for tobacco cessation programs, we don’t yet have data showing that the same intervention produces better results in groups than individually
“By doing just a little every day, I can gradually let the task completely overwhelm me.” --Ashleigh Brilliant
How can you identify cohorts for group visits? • Pull diagnosis codes from billing data • ICD code 305.1, Tobacco Cessation • Create registries at patient visits • Empower your staff to enroll patients • Review pharmacy prescription data • Create an Excel file or a Registry file that you can update at scheduled intervals
Plan in advance • Schedule > 8 to12 weeks in advance • Schedule 2 to 3 MA/LPN level providers for the first 15 to 30 minutes to collect data • Reserve a room! • Prepare overheads, handouts or choose reading material in advance • Prepare chart note forms in advance
Group visit organization • Organization brings order • Disorganization produces chaos • Some chaos will occur
“In science as in love, too much concentration on technique can often lead to impotence.” --P.L. Berger
How much time do you need for a group visit? (one tested method) 4 hours for a group visit with 20 to 30 patients: 2 hours group time and 2 hours prep time (5 patients/hour of your time) • 1 hour to prepare didactic materials and to coordinate with your staff • 1 hour for chart reviews prior to the visit • 1/2 hour for 2 to 3 nurses to collect data, and for the provider to document specific plans • 1 hour to share information within the group • 1/2 hour for wrap-up
You can vary the time • Choose a group visit size that reflects your style, patient population and group visit room • You could see 10 patients during a total of 2 hours of physician time for a 1 hour group visit session • Allow 30 minutes for chart review, 30 minutes to prepare materials and 1 hour for the session (again at least 5 pts/hour of MD time)
Selecting Patient Material • Select evidence-based objectives and targets, and give them to your patients • A notebook for patients with current status and targets • A book addressing lifestyle changes • AAFP patient education handouts: www.familydoctor.org • 28-page AAFP Stop Smoking Guide: http://www.aafp.org/online/etc/medialib/aafp_org/documents/clinical/pub_health/askact/guide.Par.0001.file.tmp/StopSmokingGuide2001.pdf • Review the other tobacco cessation resources on www.askandact.org
How do you invite patients? • Willingness to enroll with the primary physician is about 50% • Create a registry of patients with tobacco use • Contact the tobacco users in your practice (e-mail, mail, postcards) • Offer 2 to 3 group visits yearly for tobacco cessation; have your staff market these sessions year round
How do you invite patients? (cont) • One month prior, write a letter to tobacco users in your practice advertising dates for you next group visit (postal mail or e-mail) • The letter encourages them to call and enroll for the group visit • Have your receptionist call 1 week later to encourage enrollment.
Chart review before the group visit (ensures quality) Addresses key targets for the specific diagnosis If you have a registry of high-risk cohort patients, this is very easy If your charts lack cohort specific targets, the first review can be lengthy, but critically important Once a template is built for the chart review, a nurse/PA/MA can add data for physicians review
Registration • First visit, during registration forms must be signed (I strongly recommend confidentiality and HIPAA forms), patients should be registered and fees collected • Thereafter, register, collect co-payment or normal appointment fee, and begin data collection
Agreement to Participate Example • I agree to meet with a group of patients and my doctor. I have the choice to be seen by my physician in this group or individually. • Like any doctor’s appointment, I agree to be responsible for the bill or co-payment associated with this doctor’s visit.
Confidentiality Form • I agree to keep all information regarding other patients at these visits private and agree not to disclose any information regarding other patients in these group visits. • I will respect others’ privacy - ok to discuss what you have learned in these sessions, but don’t mention anyone’s name outside this group!
HIPAA Issues • Receptionist should mention this issue when they register for the appointment • Signed HIPAA Disclosure Form essential • Share with your HIPAA compliance officer • Physicians should avoid sharing personal health info about a patient without “additional consent” to do so
During a Group Visit it is possible that some of my personal health information will be disclosed. For example, at a Group Visit for Tobacco Cessation, it might be assumed that everyone attending uses tobacco. Discussions may occur regarding personal health information during a group visit. I have been notified of this potential disclosure and I wish to participate in a group medical visit. I realize that I have the option of being seen individually. HIPAA Consent Example
Room set-up Horse-shoe shape works well Back corners used for nurse evals Curtain for privacy optional Put handout materials by the entry/exit door Have a cart with blood pressure cuffs, charts, materials, extra pens, etc. Consider table for tea, healthy snacks, or for cooking demos
Room Layout Nurse Nurse Projector Clip Board Screen Tea MD
Patient Role • Arrive on time • Register • Find a chair and complete subjective aspect of the SOAP (subjective, objective, assessment, plan) note • Meet with the nurse • Meet with the doctor • Return to chair
Nurse Exam Stations (2 to 3) • Maximum 3 to 4 minutes/pt (sees 10 pts/30 min) • Medical Record (EMR or paper) • New progress note completed. MD may have already made comments from chart review • Scale, BP cuff, peak flow meter, etc • Review of systems, past history, vital signs and peak flow may be completed here • Physician will complete the note and sign the progress note
MD Role • Conduct preliminary 1-on-1, face to face E/M with each patient • Signed HIPAA disclosure essential; • Clarify assessment with the patient (you smoke, it is harmful and I advise you to stop using tobacco). • Get permission to conduct balance of E/M service with group observing • Might include starting a new medication and the risks and benefits of that Rx • Put issues to address on the clip board • Private issues can be addressed at an individual follow up visit (a recent headache)
MD location during documentation time • Doctor’s station (table in the corner), or go from patient to patient (but you must have a HIPAA disclosure signed for this to work) • Don’t leave the room
How does a preceptor mix with a resident-led group visit? During the initial 30 minutes, while the patient has had data collected by the nurse, and when the provider (resident) speaks briefly with each individual, the preceptor should be available to observe and document “the key aspects of this appointment”
Prepare your chart note in advance • Have a typed, fill in the blank note for your chart reviews (examples to follow) • Fill in targets and recent labs prior with the chart review • Choose targets you want to reach for the note
Prepare your chart note in advance Nurse and patient may complete the review of systems, past history, vital signs and peak flow measurement. You must document HPI, assessment and plan for each patient. The level of service is based on medically necessary key components provided to individual patient.
Group visits are only intended for established patientsNew patients should initially be seen individuallyOtherwise, the potential patient interactions and billing aspects may become very complicated